top of page

UnderBelly's 2022
Holiday Gift Guide

lovecore sticker set etsy 1 - Amber Marz Art.jpg

Amber Marz Art

Illustrative inky and colorful stickers and gifts. Handmade with love in Madison, WI.


Smere Tactics

Smere Tactics creates bold interdisciplinary artwork. Accessories, original works and prints are constructed through a combination of relief cutting, printmaking, risograph printing, painting, drawing, collage and assemblage using sustainable or repurposed media and materials. 

7547AE37-75B5-4838-8AC0-31EC0439FBFE - Brook Johnson.jpeg

Yahara Chocolate & Tea

Midwest’s largest selection of more than 250 craft chocolate bars and 50 loose leaf teas. We also make our milk, oat, and dark chocolate bars with Wisconsin ingredients


Shop Stoughton Location: 261 W. Main St. Stoughton 53589.

FD3B94C6-5569-4A40-8017-D9556FAAF9D1 - Lauren Cornell.jpeg

Think Unique

Think Unique is a handmade jewelry brand founded in Chicago in 2018. Currently located in San Diego, CA, we offer a variety of jewelry and lifestyle goods that directly support mental health awareness and organizations.


Green Life Trading Co.

Green Life Trading Co. is a refill store that offers sustainable home and personal care items. Whether it’s in-store or online, we hope to bring a sense of eco-friendly ease into shopping for everyday essentials and inspired items.

Shop Madison Location: 1334 Williamson Street, Madison, WI 53703

Shop Milwaukee Location: 1039 S 5th St, Milwaukee, WI 53204

9668AAD3-CBE2-496D-9D66-2B5701177ECB - Soul Sisters Photography.jpeg

Soul Sisters Photography

Soul Sisters Photography specializes in newborn and maternity portraits, making it possible for you to freeze a moment in time to cherish forever.

Shop Milwaukee Location: 2625 S Greeley St, Suite 145, Milwaukee WI 53207

hireus - T.L. Dankert.jpg

T.L. Luke Art

T.L. Luke is a queer illustrator based in Madison, best known locally for her collaborations with WI State Representative Francesca Hong, Room of One's Own Bookstore, and Green Life Trading Co. Her work is whimsical, dark, witchy, political, and tongue-in-cheek; perfect for everyone in the family, especially that weird cousin you never know what to buy!

Shop Madison Location (by Appointment only): 100 S. Baldwin St, Suite 300-C, Madison WI 53703

545FFB87-B15B-4566-8D69-62FDE323A8CE - Steven Wroblewski.jpeg


Local Milwaukee icons in neon lights 🔥 Rep your city pride with bold, bright tabletop neons

99795690-3162-4531-9A0E-AD6B2FBBECE0 - Peach Beast.jpeg

Peach Beast

Peach Beast is a maker of unboring acrylic jewelry and pink inspired accessories.

6CEFD784-CEA7-491A-A0CB-BDD80EBF1120 - Saren O'Grady.jpeg

House of Gaud

House of Gaud (previously Dip Vintage) is a Milwaukee-based vintage shop specializing in unique home furnishings, decor, housewares and gifts from the 50s through 90s and Y2K. Our mission - to supply and stan your audacious home.

Shop Milwaukee Location:  2018 S 1st St, Suite 318 Milwaukee, WI 53207

IMG_9458 - Cristina Siqueira.heic

Lions Tooth

Lion's Tooth is a bookstore café in the beautiful Bay View neighborhood in Milwaukee. Offering a carefully curated selection of books and graphic novels for kids and adults, plus art, creative gifts and zines.

Shop Milwaukee Location:  2421 South Kinnickinnic Ave, Milwaukee WI 53207

Screen Shot 2022-11-07 at 3.23.33 PM - Ashley Hartman Annis.png

Ashley Hartman Annis

Trauma informed, gender inclusive zines!

Topics include abortion, fertility, menstruation, birth control, pregnancy, and being in a body. Stocking stuffers that are informative, educational, & fun.

1B87A99B-407A-4DD6-816E-B34976BD9700 - Aaron Lewis (ARLTheCraft).jpeg

Craft The Future

Craft The Future is a creative digital marketing agency. We power local brands and creatives to build community experiences that make think, laugh, and learn.

IMG_1360 - 27 Bones.jpg

Ethically sourced oddities and unique metalwork with a heavy focus on insects.

CA93213E-7114-4AEB-A149-C6396507A388 - Maggie Denman.jpeg

Small shop with VHS, vinyl, CDs, Tapes, vintage clothing and goods based in Madison WI. 

Shop Madison Location: 222 North St, Ste B, Madison, WI 53704

nurse - Artery Ink.jpeg

Artery Ink

Artery Ink creates wearable art that cultivates community through encouraging personal wellness education and fostering universal connection. All of the hand-drawn artwork is a collaborative mix of traditional pen and digital design which are then screen printed on to apparel, made into stickers, prints, cards and more! Custom apparel for your team or department is our specialty!

Shop Milwaukee Location: 2625 S Greeley St., Suite 135 Milwaukee, WI 53207

8286FB23-A9BC-4AA7-AE11-2D1AAAC514F1 - Courtney Cosgriff.jpeg


Deerloom is all about colorful, eclectic woven home decor. I love to make pieces that are truly one of a kind and bring fun to any room.

MadeleineParkerPottery3 - Madeleine Manning.jpg

Madeleine Parker Pottery

Handmade ceramics for everyday use! Madeleine uses techniques such as handbuilding, wheel throwing, gold luster application, and wood-firing to make one-of-a-kind pieces.

4CC85F8D-C728-4B75-A500-6805FA48483A - yazmin lopez.jpeg

Katharisma Cleaning LLC

Katharisma cleaning LLC is a commercial and residential cleaning company that provides top-notch cleaning services throughout Dane County. We are recognized for the quality service, and expertise.



giige is a Queer and Indigenous-owned tattoo and arts collective in Teejop//Madison, Wisconsin

Shop in person: 1236 Williamson Street, Madison WI 53703

B97E25FA-A98D-495E-A820-509CF5BB5679 - Lainie Bailen.jpeg

Lev Apparel

Lev Apparel is an Ethical Clothing Brand with Timeless designs created to end poverty & human trafficking through hope, healing & restoration



Moody is a monthly handmade zine publication made up of artist contributions with an emphasis on queer and BIPOC creatives. Featured artists share not only images of work, but stories, poems, notes on their creative process, QR codes to online content, and whatever else has been on their minds. On and off of its pages, Moody aims to connect creative peers, amplify diverse voices, and put money into the pockets of artists.

Shop Milwaukee Location:  Sherman Phoenix Marketplace Basement, 3536 W Fond Du Lac Ave Milwaukee, WI

2 (1).png

Communication Madison

Communication Madison is a sober, all ages arts and music nonprofit based in Madison WI. Our retail space has a range of artwork, zines, accessories and home decor created by over 80 artists who all have ties to Wisconsin.

Shop Madison Location: 2645 Milwaukee St. Madison WI 53704

6BDC7A46-E09C-4BEC-B229-C602935CA61E - Hillary Gunn.jpeg

Return To Odd Shop

Handpicked peculiar goods both vintage and modern.

Shop in person at Boneset Records: 222 North Street, Suite B, Madison WI

4E2D3A41-4A44-4D4C-A668-A3B417D53198 - Gauri Bansal.jpeg

Prettyful Creations

Speciliazing in Hand wood burned gifts and decor. Workshops and private events.

Afewgooodthings02 - Hannah Nelson.JPG

A Few Good Things by Hannah Nelson

A Few Good Things is an ever-changing art and lifestyle brand inspired by books, food, nature, and dreams. We offer a selection of art prints, stickers, zines, and other paper goods.

2295EEB0-D64B-46A6-AE6D-C637B5222B72 - Soul Sisters Photography.jpeg

The Wild Ones

The Wild Ones is filled with organic and fair trade-certified pieces for you and your littles. We also carry small shop favorites from around the world.

Shop Milwaukee Location: 2625 S Greeley St, Suite 145, Milwaukee WI 53207

DSC_5611 - Jessica Featherstone.jpg

Close to the Heart

Wisconsin's premiere maternity and postpartum boutique. We specialize in helping women transition through early motherhood through clothing and support.

Shop Milwaukee Location: 217 N Main St Thiensville, WI 53092

20220416_101824 - Laura Falkenberg.jpg


Handmade, small batch art and home goods created by local artists with developmental disabilities in Dane County, WI. Original paintings, prints, and drawings as well as jewelry, ceramics, and knit wear. About 40 resident artists are represented, supported, and mentored by ArtWorking.


Shop Madison Location: 1966 S. Stoughton Road Madison, WI 53716

CasieVogelButt1 - Rachal Duggan.jpg


Rachal Duggan is a Milwaukee based Illustrator. Known for her highly coveted booty portraits, Rachal travels for pop-up events where she draws on the spot and offers her custom-drawn butts online along with many other illustrated goodies!

IMG_20220311_083253_120 - Jess Goehner.jpg


Directive is handcrafted, modern leather bags and accessories made by two hands in Milwaukee. Focusing on functional forms, bold and classic colors, we make leathergoods you can live with.

18B587E7-EF6E-459F-BDA9-452E485C3989 - Christy Grace.jpeg

Art of Christy

Inspired by all things curious, Art of Christy creates some lovely and quirky gift options including art prints, pins, stickers, and a coloring book. Christy also makes unique hand-painted and nature-filled pendants and earrings.

27A0B90D-E4DA-49AC-8942-115FC36A0E17 - Avalon Clare.jpeg

Avalon Clare Illustration

Avalon Clare is a digital illustrator, designer, artist, and feminist inspired by Lisa Frank and Patrick Nagel. Their eclectic portraits of humans and animals are available as stickers, 5x7 prints, and pins.

bottom of page